Heimat Is a Space in Time


A note to our readers:

Many venues listed on Screen Slate have announced closures lasting until at least the end of March or indefinitely. This includes Anthology Film Archives, Film at Lincoln Center, Light Industry, MoMA, and Spectacle. We are doing our best to monitor these and update them, and we'll share notices on Twitter. Because all arts institutions, regardless of relative or perceived size or scale are extremely vulnerable, we highly recommend that readers in a position to support them do so, and we and have linked to their donate/membership pages above.

New Yorkers have been officially advised to avoid crowds, and we encourage readers to consider the most vulnerable in our community before attending any public events. A forecast published today by the New York Times shows that without measures such as ending public gatherings and closing workplaces — and the sooner, the better — 1 million Americans could die. Executives, managers, and administrators are faced with difficult, delicate decisions. Closures may have adverse effects on venues, distributors, artists, and employees, and we as a community must resolve to support them.

Screen Slate currently has text published for screenings through Sunday. We’ll continue to blast these out as normal through the weekend and note how to view things remotely as possible. We hope you enjoy reading about these films and seek them out to view at home or after the pandemic subsides.

Over the next few days, the Screen Slate brain trust is discussing how to move forward during this strange time. It is unlikely that we will continue to publish listings. Nevertheless, we’ve published 365 days without fail for more than nine years, and we’re all enthusiastic about keeping the streak alive. We're kicking around a lot of ideas about how to maintain a spirit of community and cinematic discovery during this time and look forward to sharing them. And we hope getting your Screen Slate email every morning around 10am helps you to maintain some small semblance of comfort and normalcy.

Thanks for your readership and patience, and wishing you well.

Best regards,
Jon Dieringer

Screen Slate Founder/Editor


The first shot of the film gives a sense of its general bearing: A patient, steady tilt up a rusted signpost in the middle of the woods. At the top, a hand-painted message is translated "According to legend, here stood Grandmother's house." Nearby are corrugated metal cut-outs of the hunter, the wolf, the grandmother, and Little Red Riding Hood, the martyred reminder that evil may come in familiar clothing.

After this brief prologue, Heimat Is a Space in Time proceeds in black and white for three-and-a-half hours, spanning two world wars and four generations of German intellectuals. Thomas Heise's own family archives are paired with cinematographer Stefan Neuberger's present-day footage. The documents include school assignments and identification papers, résumés and recipes, letters of entreaty and betrothal, diary entries, children's drawings, and much else besides. For the non-German-speaking audience, the eye must learn to flit between the impressive images and the dense narration, translated in subtitles. Fortunately, Heise's voice is a compelling guide. Emptied of all dramatic affect, it achieves an easy proximity with those for whom he speaks.

In one sequence, we scan for half an hour a scroll of names and addresses, most appearing alongside ominous blue checkmarks. Meanwhile, Heise reads a series of letters from his great-grandparents in 1942 as they await their deportation to the Polish camps. "Life is becoming all the more beautiful," Elsa Hirschhorn writes to her daughter, "Today we had very good fried potatoes." Here and elsewhere, the silence of the receiving party is striking and terrible. That only one set of letters survives emphasizes one of Heise's central theses: a confusion of fragments is often more truthful than the coherence of narrative.

Neuberger's camera returns frequently to the labor camp at Zerbst, where Wolfgang and Hans Heise – as punishment for their “miscegenated” births – were made to build a Nazi airstrip. The old barracks still stand, now with huge wind turbines looming above them. The film's other visual fixation is with railways of all kinds, from rapid transit to freight. The trains invoke the human cargo of the Holocaust, but also provide a metaphor for the family's pervasive fatalism. Late one night, a brakeman cuts cargo cars away from each other so they can be sorted by the switch into the yard.

"The film is about people who cannot escape their history," Heise has said. After the fall of the Third Reich came the bifurcation of Germany and the implementation of a Communist regime in the East. One sequence pairs a declassified Stasi neighborhood surveillance report on the Heise household with images of a swan prodding at some rotting fish carcass. The liberal capitalism to follow would be too late to torment the Heises for long – besides Thomas, the surviving members are in hospitals and nursing homes by the film's end. Instead, we find its victims on a morning U-bahn platform, wearing Yankees caps and military fatigues, glancing nervously into the camera.

Home viewing note: today was to be Heimat is a Space in Time's US theatrical premiere run. It is distributed by Icarus, whose catalog is available to stream on OVID.tv, where it will presumably arrive in the future.

Past Screenings